Homeowners in Millburn's historic districts could soon face steeper fees and a longer paperwork checklist before touching their home's exterior.

The Millburn Township Committee introduced Ordinance 2780-26 on Oct. 20, a measure that would rewrite the application rules for the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC), according to the township's public notice. A public hearing is scheduled for Tuesday, Nov. 10, at 7 p.m. at the Millburn Education Center, 434 Millburn Ave.

The ordinance would replace the HPC's existing Certificate of Appropriateness application and checklist with a two-track system separating minor projects from larger ones that go before the full commission.

What homeowners would need to submit

Under the proposed checklist, every application would require property information, a survey marked with the proposed changes, photographs of the full building facade and the specific work area, and a written narrative describing the scope of work and materials.

Minor applications cover repairs, replacements or installations that do not involve additions, demolitions or changes to rooflines. Those would not require a full commission hearing, and the ordinance states approval can usually come within two weeks. The fee: $200.

Bigger projects tell a different story. Applications for facade alterations, additions or new construction would need existing and proposed site plans, exterior elevation drawings, scaled construction drawings, detailed material specifications with manufacturer cut sheets, and 3D renderings. Projects inside a historic district would also require streetscape photographs taken from across the street and a color rendering showing the new work alongside neighboring buildings.

Full commission cases would carry a $1,500 escrow fee on top of the $200 application fee. Hoodline reported that the current application form, adopted in 2017, lists a $750 escrow fee for full commission applications.

Demolitions face the steepest bar

Proposed demolitions would require a complete photography record of all exterior elevations and interior spaces, a statement explaining the need for demolition, and a written and pictorial record of the building's history and architectural features. Where an applicant claims no alternative to demolition exists, the ordinance would require documentation of good-faith attempts to sell or relocate the building. Properties in areas flagged by the New Jersey Historic Preservation Office as likely to contain archaeological resources would need a Phase IA archaeological study.

How the ordinance got here

The HPC itself had been working on application updates before the Township Committee acted. At the commission's June 4 meeting, a discussion item titled "Updates to HPC Application" was carried to a July 21 meeting, according to HPC minutes. Board of Adjustment representative Gary Rosen said at that June meeting that it would be helpful for the checklist to also require a zoning form, similar to Zoning Board of Adjustment applications.

David R. Cosgrove serves as the Township Committee's liaison to the HPC, according to the commission's webpage. Alison Canfield chairs the commission, with Zachary Davis as vice chair.

The ordinance must also be referred to the Planning Board for a consistency review with the township's master plan. The Planning Board has 35 days after referral to report back.

What's next

The public hearing on Nov. 10 begins at 7 p.m. Doors open at 6:45 p.m. Residents can review the agenda at the township's Agenda Center or contact the Municipal Clerk's Office at 973-564-7092. If adopted, the ordinance would take effect after final passage, publication and filing with the Essex County Planning Board.